The 911,000 Phantom Jobs: The Week Reality Officially Hit the Market

Introduction

It’s one of the most confusing times to be an investor. On one hand, you see stock market tickers flashing near all-time highs. On the other, you might have a nagging feeling that the real economy—the world of jobs, household budgets, and small businesses—is telling a different story.

This week, that feeling was confirmed. The U.S. government released its official annual benchmark of jobs data, and the numbers revealed a shocking truth: nearly a million jobs that were reported over the last year never actually existed.

This isn't just another data point; it's a fundamental revision of our economic reality. The "strong and resilient" economy that justified market optimism was, in large part, a statistical illusion. This week, we'll dive deep into what this means, why the market's foundation is more fragile than it appears, and how you can prepare for what comes next.

The Main Story: The Labor Market's Sobering Reality Check

The single most important event this week was a government report called the Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW). While it doesn't get the same media attention as the monthly jobs report, it is far more accurate. Think of the monthly report as a quick poll, while the QCEW is the official, verified census.

This week, the QCEW revealed that job growth between March 2024 and March 2025 was overstated by 911,000 jobs—the largest downward revision in U.S. history. To put this in perspective, imagine a company announcing record profits all year, only to issue a statement later saying, "Actually, we need to revise those numbers down by more than half." That's essentially what just happened to the U.S. labor market.

This revision confirms that the economy has been significantly weaker than we were told for over a year. It validates what other, less-publicized indicators have been signaling for months:

• Canadians Are Facing a Similar Story: This isn't just a U.S. problem. Canada's job market is also showing significant signs of stress, with a rising unemployment rate and a falling participation rate, which means more people are giving up looking for work. The strong Canadian jobs number reported for June now seems like a statistical anomaly and will likely face a significant downward revision in the future, just as the U.S. numbers did.

• People Are Working Less: Another critical data point mainstream media often ignores is the average weekly hours worked. It’s one thing if fewer people are being hired; it’s another when the people who do have jobs are working less. This indicator is now at levels previously seen only during major downturns like 2008 and 2020. This signals that businesses are cutting back hours before they resort to layoffs—a clear sign of falling demand.

Other Key Insights from the Week

While the jobs revision was the main event, other signals this week confirmed the market's fragile foundation:

• A Dangerously Narrow Rally: The market's impressive gains are not as robust as they seem. The rally is being powered by a very small number of mega-cap technology stocks. In fact, the top 10 U.S. stocks now represent a record 37% of the entire U.S. equity market, a level of concentration that surpasses even the peak of the dot-com bubble. This isn't a sign of a healthy, broad-based recovery; it's a sign of immense risk, where the fate of the entire market rests on the shoulders of just a few companies.

• The 'Good News' on Earnings Isn't What It Seems: You may have heard that many companies are "beating" their earnings expectations. However, a closer look reveals this isn't due to booming sales. Instead, many companies are achieving these results through aggressive cost-cutting, productivity optimizations, and layoffs. While efficiency is good, relying on cost-cutting instead of sales growth is a defensive move that signals a weak economic environment, not a strong one.

• A Critical Warning from the Real Economy: The economic weakness is now clearly spreading to the services sector, which had been the last pillar of strength holding up the economy. The ISM service sector backlog index—a simple measure of how much future work companies have lined up—just fell to a 15-year low, a level last seen in the depths of the 2009 financial crisis. When backlogs dry up, companies have less work for their employees, which is often a direct leading indicator of future layoffs.

Noteworthy Signals on My Radar

Here are a few other brief but important developments from the week:

• A Telling Google Search: Google Trends data shows an exponential increase in searches for terms like "sell my house fast," "give car back," and "bankruptcy lawyer," signaling significant financial distress for everyday households.

• Sovereign Debt Cracks: Fitch has downgraded France's debt rating. This is important because many large institutions, like pension funds, are not allowed to hold debt that isn't considered safe or "investment grade." The upcoming reviews from Moody's and S&P Global are now critical to watch.

• A Technical Warning: The S&P 500 is currently trading at extremely overbought levels, near the top of its trend channel since 2009 and two standard deviations above its long-term average. The last six times the market was this overbought, a correction of 20% or more followed (in 2008, 2015, 2018, 2020, 2022, and 2025).

• Projections, Not Profits: Oracle's stock jumped 37% this week, fueling optimism in the AI sector. However, this was based on future projections and a massive backlog of contracts, not on current results—the company actually missed its recent earnings expectations.

Looking Forward

The next week is pivotal, with several major catalysts that will shape the market's direction. I will be closely monitoring these key dates:

• Tuesday, September 16th: U.S. Retail Sales data for August.

• Wednesday, September 17th: A critical day with interest rate decisions from both the Bank of Canada (BoC) and the U.S. Federal Reserve (FOMC). While markets are pricing in an approximately 90% chance of a 0.25% rate cut from both central banks, I believe there is a significant possibility that the Fed could deliver a more aggressive 0.50% cut. This would be a move to "catch-up" after holding rates steady in July, especially given this week's weak economic data.

• Friday, September 19th: "Quadruple Witching," the simultaneous expiration of stock options, index options, stock futures, and index futures, which often leads to heightened market volatility.

Your Path Forward: A Tailored Next Step

Navigating a market where the headlines don't match the data can be unsettling. The key is to move from reacting to the news to building a confident plan based on your personal situation. Your next step depends on where you are on your investor journey.

• For Investors at Levels 0-2 (The Saver & Delegator): Your first "smart" move is to stop overpaying. Book my Portfolio Efficiency Audit to get a clear, educational overview of how to potentially cut hidden fees and save thousands annually.

• For Investors at Level 3 (The DIY Learner): If you're ready to replace guesswork with a repeatable process, book the Jumpstart Session to master your first protective strategy and learn to invest with confidence.

• For Investors Seeking to Optimize (Levels 4-5): If you're ready for ongoing support to refine your process and achieve mastery, book a free strategy call to discuss my Monthly Coaching programs.